Dogs in Laboratories at UMass Chan Medical School: Complaints, Federal Citations, the University’s Response and What the Debate Means for Animal Research

Dogs in Laboratories at UMass Chan Medical School: Complaints, Federal Citations, the University’s Response and What the Debate Means for Animal Research | Sustainable Action Now
Sustainable Action NowStop Testing on Animals
Animal Research · Oversight · Massachusetts

Stop Testing on Animals · Oversight

Dogs in Laboratories at UMass Chan Medical School: Complaints, Federal Citations, the University’s Response and What the Debate Means for Animal Research

A year of complaints from People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals has put the dog research program at a Massachusetts medical school under scrutiny. The university says it follows the rules. A federal bill moving through Congress is changing the larger conversation about how new medicines are tested.

The allegations are PETA’s, the oversight bodies are public, and the policy debate reaches well beyond one campus.

A video released by the animal protection group PETA asks viewers to imagine their own dog spending its life in a laboratory. The video is part of a campaign directed at the University of Massachusetts Chan Medical School in Worcester, where, according to PETA, dogs are bought from commercial breeders and used in invasive experiments. The campaign has moved from a single set of complaints into a sustained effort that has involved federal agencies, a state health department, a veterinary licensing board and the courts. The university disputes the characterization of its program and says it holds itself to the highest standards of laboratory animal welfare. Because both the allegations and the response are part of the public record, the situation offers a useful look at how animal research is overseen in the United States and how that system is changing. Related reporting is collected in the Sustainable Action Now coverage of animal testing.

Video from PETA. The views in it are the organization’s.
Dec. 10, 2025Date of PETA’s complaints to USDA, state and NIH offices
2Veterinarians PETA says staffed the program for 17 months
~50,000Dogs a year used in U.S. research, per one congressional estimate
2022Year the FDA Modernization Act 2.0 became law

What PETA Alleges

PETA says it began investigating after an insider at UMass Chan provided photographs and video. On December 10, 2025, the organization sent complaints to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Animal Care division, the Massachusetts Department of Public Health and the National Institutes of Health’s Office of Laboratory Animal Welfare, and it announced the filings on December 16. Among its allegations are that dogs were kept deliberately thin so they would stay under the weight thresholds that would require larger kennels, that animals received inadequate care after surgery, and that pigs developed dead tissue on their ears, tails and toes after invasive cardiac procedures. PETA also says the school employed only two veterinarians from March 2024 to August 14, 2025, a staffing level it argues was too low for the size of the program. In January 2026, it filed a further complaint with the state veterinary licensing board concerning two veterinarians at the school.

In February 2026, PETA sent a letter to Chancellor Michael F. Collins raising concerns about experiments on dogs purchased as puppies in the laboratory of Matthew Gounis, who PETA says has also chaired the university’s Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee since at least May 2022. The committee is the federally required body that reviews and approves animal research protocols, and PETA argues the dual role creates a conflict of interest. Later that month, PETA announced that the USDA had cited the university for violations of the Animal Welfare Act in Gounis’s laboratory. In April, PETA said a whistleblower had reported that the dogs were euthanized ahead of an inspection by the state health department. The university’s response to that specific claim was not available in the coverage reviewed for this article. The group has continued with a newspaper advertisement in June and, according to its announcement, public records lawsuits against UMass Chan and UMass Amherst over access to animal care committee records. PETA’s materials also name commercial breeders, including Marshall BioResources and Oak Hill Genetics, as sources of research dogs.

The University’s Position

UMass Chan has responded to the reporting in general terms. In a statement to the local news outlet Patch, the school said it is committed to upholding the highest standards of laboratory animal welfare, that it remains dedicated to rigorous compliance with all regulations governing the humane treatment of animals in research, and that it abides by the policies and laws that apply to animal care. PETA’s own August 2026 letter to NIH, which relies on records it obtained from the university, indicates the school conducted a program wide review after repeated incidents and instituted changes including additional daily water line checks and retraining of animal care staff, although PETA contends comparable failures continued in 2025. Institutions that conduct animal research generally maintain that regulated animal studies remain necessary where no validated alternative exists, and that inspections, committee review and corrective action are the mechanisms designed to catch and fix problems. The two accounts differ most on whether the problems cited reflect isolated lapses or systemic failure, and that question is for regulators to resolve.

How Oversight Works

Research on dogs in the United States is governed by several overlapping layers. The USDA enforces the Animal Welfare Act, which sets standards for housing and care and requires inspections of registered facilities. The NIH’s Office of Laboratory Animal Welfare oversees institutions that receive federal research funds and holds each to a written assurance of compliance. Inside every institution, the animal care and use committee must review protocols, including whether painful procedures have been searched for alternatives. Massachusetts adds its own research animal regulations, which is why PETA also went to the state health department. Members of the public can contact any of these bodies. The USDA Animal Care division accepts complaints about regulated facilities, the NIH Office of Laboratory Animal Welfare reviews concerns at federally funded institutions, and UMass Chan Medical School maintains its own public information and media offices.

Read the Claims Carefully

Most of the specific allegations described here originate with PETA and a confidential source, and PETA is an advocacy organization that opposes animal experimentation. Federal citations, where reported, are described by PETA, and readers can look to the agencies’ public inspection records for the official findings. UMass Chan has not accepted the characterization of its program.

The Larger Policy Shift

The campus dispute is unfolding while federal policy on animal testing is changing. The FDA Modernization Act 2.0, signed in December 2022, removed an 84 year old requirement that new drugs be tested on animals before human trials. It did not ban animal testing, and, as Cruelty Free International points out, neither that law nor its successor requires researchers to use an available non-animal method in its place. In April 2025 the FDA announced a plan to phase out animal testing requirements for monoclonal antibodies and certain other drugs. The FDA Modernization Act 3.0, which would direct the agency to update its regulations to match the 2022 law, passed the U.S. House of Representatives in July 2026 and has bipartisan sponsors in both chambers. Its backers argue that techniques such as human cell models, organs on chips and computational toxicology can predict human responses better and faster than animal tests. Readers should check the bill’s current status in the Senate, because it can change.

Congressman Vern Buchanan’s office estimates that about 50,000 dogs are used in laboratory experiments and testing in the United States each year, along with millions of other animals. Researchers who work with dogs, often in cardiovascular and device studies, say the animals provide information that cell cultures cannot yet fully replace, while critics say the evidence for human relevance is weak and that alternatives are maturing quickly. Both views are likely to be tested in coming years, and the FDA’s public comment period on its animal testing policy runs through December 7, 2026.

What Individuals Can Do

For readers who want to follow or influence the issue, the options are modest and public. They can read the inspection records that the USDA posts, contact members of Congress about the pending legislation, and use product certification programs when buying household and personal care items. The Leaping Bunny Program certifies brands that do not test on animals, and the Rise for Animals database tracks laboratory inspection records and violations. Those who want a different perspective can also look at the research community’s own explanations of why it uses animals and how it reviews that work. The question of whether dogs should be used in medical research at all is a values debate, and the facts available to settle it are still developing.

UMass Chan Medical SchoolDogs in LaboratoriesAnimal TestingPETAFDA Modernization Act 3.0Animal Welfare ActNon-Animal Research Methods
Sustainable Action Now · Stop Testing on Animals